Welcome to the Pie Shop!


Each Rustic Inn pie is made to order and baked, then frozen to maintain freshness. The pies are shipped in compostable packaging with ice bricks. Upon arrival, the pies should be kept refrigerated or frozen until ready to serve. Simply let the pie thaw and serve! Instructions are included with each shipment.

Pies are shipped on Monday and Tuesdays only. When your order pies online, you can purchase one or two pies at a time, in case you can’t decide on just one. Orders need to be placed at least 48 hours in advance.

Please feel free to contact us with any questions at 218.834.2488.